I keep an eye out for American popular cultural references to ancient Chinese philosophy.  So, imagine my surprise when I chanced upon this story from ESPN: "Amare Stoudemire, Taoist?"

It seems that the Phoenix Suns basketball player has gotten into a classical text – only it's not a Taoist book, but Sun Tzu:

"They call me 'Sun Tzu,' " Stoudemire said. "That's what they call me
nowadays. The methods I use from the ancient general, Sun Tzu, is the
leadership method. I feel like using that will help my leadership and
help us to get over the hump. I'm going to apply those tactics and
those rules to how we're going to approach battle and win."

It's not clear why the writer then links Sun to Taoism.  True, the notion of "winning without fighting" does have Taoist-like subtlety to it.  But Sun Tzu is a man of action, a man who tells us we must engage in exhaustive planning and preparation before we enter battle.  Wu wei – doing nothingis decidedly not his way of thinking.  Sun Tzu, I think it is safe to say, is not a Taoist.

OK, maybe I should not expect an ESPN writer to get these distinctions.  But I think the journalist he cites goes too far when she crticizes Stoudemire's invocation of Sun Tzu.  Apparently, the star player is suggesting that he might leave the team after this season, and the journalist comments:

Surely somewhere in the Chinese general's book, The Art of War, is a
chapter that says conjecture about your possible departure a month
removed from Suns training camp is not the right approach to unifying a
team, let alone a fan base.

Sigh. Stoudemire has done it
again, irking some with his comments Tuesday that the 2009-2010 season
"might be my farewell tour." Poor timing? You bet. Worthy of an uproar?
Hardly…

… So although the Sun Tzu bit might seem contrived
to some, it's Stoudemire trying to flex his leadership muscles and,
sure, maybe trying to market himself a little bit. This is the NBA,
after all.

But maybe Stoudemire really does know Sun Tzu.   Maybe he takes to heart The Art of War's injunction that "war is deception."  Perhaps he is just saying that this might be his last season with the Suns in order to create a media commotion, to draw attention to himself and take the pressure off of his teammates….

Or maybe I reading way too much into this….

Sam Crane Avatar

Published by

Categories: , ,

3 responses to “Sun Tzu is not a Taoist”

  1. funkspiel Avatar
    funkspiel

    Wu wei is knowing when to act and when not to.

    Like

  2. Casey Kochmer Avatar

    more to the point
    Sun Tzu embraced many angles of how to fight some of which are very Taoist in style.
    Taoists will still at times fight:wu wei or not, but the truth is 99 times out of 100 you win the battle long before the fight, so it only appears that Taoist rarely give action to a fight: Since you let the foe use their energy while in wu wei you patiently let the foe work work hard at losing their own battle. All in all know your heart and know your foe, in order to minimize actions on your part to give any foe less to work against upon you.
    But when action is called for, make it decisive quick and to the point…
    Besides at the time period Sun Tzu wrote how can you not get a fusion of philosophy in his works as the very period saw such philosophies evolving as part of the times / flux it was written within?
    To try to separate out the strands of philosophy in Sun Tzu is to chase the the strands of breeze that compose the wind itself.
    If a Taoist were to fight, they would take much of what Sun Tzu wrote to heart, and in the end isn’t that a very Taoist statement/ measurement of a work of writing, something to be taken to heart as a manner of flowing with the world?

    Like

  3. Travis Avatar
    Travis

    The first thing the Tao Te Ching says is that it cannot be explained, so who are we to try and label it. The Tao meshes with anything whether it be the Art of War or the NBA. I believe in the Bible as well as the Tao.

    Like

Leave a comment