I am reading Mencius with my class now; so, when I heard the news today of Eliot Spitzer’s embarrassment, I wondered what Mencius might say.  I found this passage which, while evincing a rather different sensibility toward mistresses than that of our own time, ends with a warning about ambition that wives of high profile politicians might want to take to heart. 

There was a man in Ch’i who lived with his wife and mistress.  When he went out, he always came home stuffed with wine and meat.  One day his wife asked who his companions were, and he told her they were all men of wealth and renown. So she said to the mistress: "When he goes out, he always comes home stuffed with wine and meat.  I ask who his companions are, and he says they’re all men of wealth and renown.  But we’ve never had such illustrious guests here in our house.  I’m going to follow him and see where he goes."

She rose early the next morning and followed him everywhere he went.  But no one in all the city even stopped to talk with him.  Finally he went out to the graveyard east of the city, and there begged leftovers from someone performing sacrifices.  He didn’t get enough, so he went to beg from someone at another grave.  That’s how he stuffed himself full.

The wife returned home and told the mistress what she’d seen, then said: "A woman looks to her husband for direction and hope throughout life, and this is what ours is like."  Together they railed against their husband and wept in the courtyard.  Later, knowing nothing of this, the husband came swaggering in to impress his women.

In the eyes of the noble-minded, when a man chases after wealth and renown, profit and position, it is rare that his women aren’t disgraced and driven to tears. (8.33)

Sam Crane Avatar

Published by

Categories: ,

5 responses to “Eliott Spitzer and Mencius”

  1. Bill Avatar
    Bill

    Hmm… So lying about what one is doing and pretention to one’s friends and family is an ancient Chinese sectet and cultural heritage.

    Like

  2. Sam Avatar

    Mencius is using this as a negative example. In the last paragraph the noble-minded, to which Mencius aspires, would recognize this fellow as base, trying to create an impression of wealth and influence to impress his wife and mistress when, in fact, he is disgracing himself and them. Thus, Mencius hopes that Chinese civilization will avoid this sort of bad behavior.

    Like

  3. isha Avatar
    isha

    opps…just got this … as the lengendary cliche goes: fasten the seat belt … this is going to be a rough ride …
    http://news.bbc.co.uk/2/hi/middle_east/7290826.stm
    Could the Masters shed some light on this? ( seriously )
    Isha

    Like

  4. Luis Andrade Avatar

    Sam, you are too kind to explain yourself and Mencius’ message. Some people aren’t even able to see the fly on the tip of their noses (or feel it)…

    Like

  5. Mill Avatar

    The message is giant eared politicians should be wary of doing dirty deals with giant schnozzed campaign donors.

    Like

Leave a reply to Mill Cancel reply